By Mary Elizabeth Wakefield, LAc, Dipl. Ac., MS, MM and Kelly
Clady-Giramma, LAc, Dipl. OM
In this column, we historically have focused much of our attention on
a potential reconfiguration of aging. Such a profound cultural shift
seems to be on the agenda as our predominantly baby boomer generation
approaches those incontrovertible milestones of seniority.
However, the previous generation that fostered this huge demographic
has long since passed over that threshold. Many have been consigned to,
or voluntarily incarcerated themselves in, rest homes and assisted care
facilities around the country. Consequently, their children already have
begun to confront the unpleasant realities of the present Western
paradigm of aging, characterized by a profound marginalization of the
elderly.
Even more disquieting is the docility with which this
generation of our elders has chosen to acquiesce to this model. In the
past few years, I have seen my mother and her sister (both formerly
active, creative octogenarians) fearfully surrender their autonomy and
their family homes in order to receive protection in the bosom of the
elder care system. Each has embarked resolutely on that inevitable
pilgrimage toward the next world, their steady progress abetted by
liberal doses of "corrective" Western medications and immersion in an
environment which might be described, at best, as minimally stimulating
and, at worst, stultifying. Here, the omnipresent drone of television
sets in room after room functions as a poor substitute for interaction
with the outside world - the realm of the more youthful and vital. In
the sterile precincts of "God's waiting room," even if the body remains
somewhat hale, the mind quickly atrophies.
As an Oriental medical
practitioner, it is more than a little frustrating to witness this
latest downward trajectory of their lives. Some of their symptoms might
be alleviated in time by our medicine and enable them to live out their
remaining years to their fullest. However, neither will permit me to
intervene. Their faith in the infallibility of Western medicine is
absolute and acceptance of their lowered social status within our
youth-besotted culture is by now a foregone conclusion.
I offer
these observations by way of contrast with what my colleague, Kelly
Clady-Giramma, contributes in the following article. With a viewpoint
acquired during her recent sojourn in China, she presents a culture not
unlike a variety of others around the world, both advanced and
indigenous, where the wisdom and experience of the elderly is both
honored and celebrated and they remain a valued part of society.
Aging:
A Cultural Construct
"Youth is the gift of nature,
but age is a work of art." - Stanislaw Lec
"When grace
is joined with wrinkles, it is adorable.There is an unspeakable dawn in
happy old age." - Victor Hugo
When Americans think about
what it means to grow old, they often have negative associations such as
wasting away in loneliness in a convalescent home, having limited
financial resources, being in constant pain, suffering from memory
lapses or even Alzheimer's - being generally unwell and unhappy. Ask a
typical Chinese person what they associate with aging and they likely
will paint a much different picture: being surrounded by family members
of all ages, being respected by family and society, enjoying playing
cards every day with neighbors their own age, having a certain amount of
aches and pains but not being incapacitated, taking grandchildren to
school by bike and enjoying leisure time that they didn't have in their
youth.
These contrasting stereotypical pictures of aging do not
always mirror reality. They do, nonetheless, illustrate the large
influence society can have on an individual's aging process. Having
spent most of the past three years living in China, I was affected
deeply by the love and adoration people have there for the elderly.
Although many Chinese have adopted more Western, quick-paced lifestyles
in the past 10 to 15 years, they still adhere to the Confucian ideal of
honoring their elders. They don't merely just give up their bus seats to
older folks, they integrate them into every aspect of life. I believe
it is this attitude in large part that accounts for the fact that
seniors in China, often with deep wrinkles and weathered faces from
years of struggle and hardship, still have vibrancy and serene
contentedness I've rarely observed in their American peers.
Young
people in China seem much less assured and confident than their parents
and grandparents despite the fact that most of them have grown up with
material comfort previously unknown to past generations. These fortunate
young Chinese, unfortunately, rarely have the time to enjoy
themselves. From the time Chinese children begin preschool, life is all
about passing various exams and pleasing parents and teachers. There is
little time for true relaxation until college which, according to all my
Chinese friends, is far less stressful than their elementary and high
school years. After college, they begin the serious business of finding
work in China's ever-competitive job market, next comes a spouse and
then that long-awaited grandchild who will be doted on and sacrificed to
the nth degree by both parents and two sets of grandparents.
If these goals are not fulfilled by age 30 or so (earlier for women),
they will be looked down upon a bit by all but the most liberal-minded
families.
Fast-forward to retirement. Assuming that a person in
their 60s in China has at least one responsible adult child on whom to
rely, they can finally live a little. (It should be noted, however, that
childless Chinese run a similar risk to their American counterparts, in
that governmental and pension support is not as much as it used to be
in the old days of Communism. The proverbial Chinese "iron rice bowl"
has indeed been broken by current-day capitalistic economic practices.)
Old people are seen in China as offering a lot of experience and wisdom
and they are respected for having survived so long.
The
Race Does Not Necessarily Belong to the Swiftest
Survival
is a concept not taken lightly throughout Chinese history. This
probably is the reason why Chinese traditionally didn't mark birthdays
until they turned 60 years old. To this day, grandparents get big
parties with a lot of to-do and children usually are just given a bowl
of special noodles (a sign of long life) to mark their far less
auspicious birthdays. The attitude is "Anyone can be young; it takes
talent to be old!" A person's 80th birthday is believed to be
the pinnacle of life that everyone aspires to and every birthday after
that becomes more and more special.
What a contrast this is to
our own adrenaline, youth and speed addicted society. To slow down here
in any way, even temporarily, implies weakness and inferiority. It is
interesting to note that, according to TCM medical theory, children are
"pure yang," a fact that anyone who has tried to chase a
toddler around can attribute to! It is a misnomer, however, to assume
that old people must be "pure yin." The whole point of life,
according to Chinese medicine, is to try to retain as much of your yang
energy, vitality and health as possible throughout every stage of life.
(This is why those same hyperactive toddlers need to sleep so much!)
What may perplex some adrenaline junkies is that the only way to have
any yang (warm, energetic, active) energy left over when you
get old is by balancing it with yin (restorative, cooling)
activities and behaviors before you get old. Rather than the
theory "use it or lose it," we might substitute instead with "abuse it
(your body) and lose it!"
The intention of Chinese medicine is to
provide tools for cultivating healthy yang qi and vitality.
The Taoist sages who originally laid down the precepts for Chinese
medicine wanted a way to achieve immortality. They weren't concerned
with remaining young per se, they simply wanted to remain healthy and
live a long, and possibly indefinite, life. The three main ways to do
this, they believed, were through proper diet, using medicinal herbs and
learning to strengthen inner qi through mind-body exercises
such as tai chi and qigong.
There are numerous
references to longevity and good health for the old in contemporary TCM
curriculum. The herb wei ling xian (Clematis root) is
well-known for its ability to treat wind-damp-type arthritic pain. Its
name in Chinese literally means "Awesome Spiritual Immortal." Then there
is the Yang Lao point (SI 6) which means "To Nourish the Old"
(hence, the title of this piece), and which is famous for treating low
back, neck and shoulder pain in the elderly.
In China, beauty is
not something which is merely confined to the young, though there is
tremendous pressure on young women and men to be attractive. In fact, it
often is a requirement for gainful employment these days. Older
generations are seen as having inner strength and beauty which gives
them a sense of pride and dignity.
Older Chinese people preserve
their vital qi with many health-promoting strategies. They
frequently take tonic herbs such as ginseng (ren shen), reishi
mushroom, cordyceps (dong chong xia cao) or the formula jin
cui shen qi wan to preserve their kidney qi. Another
phenomenon, which anyone who has traveled to China has witnessed, is
that many older people do tai chi or other outdoor exercise for
an hour or more per day, come rain or shine. The idea of being fit is
not reserved for the young. In fact, exercise is a luxury for which most
Chinese in their 20s and 30s cannot find the time, whereas their
grandparents have ample time to while away the hours stretching and
doing qigong or tai chi in the public parks. Many
Chinese people in their 70s and 80s can put young American yoga
enthusiasts to shame with their muscular strength and joint flexibility.
I commonly saw people two generations older than me kick one leg up to
their nose with grace and ease I haven't personally experienced since I
was 25!
In contrast to China's reverence for the old, America's
obsession with youth comes in large part from an inability to accept the
impermanence of life. TCM theory states that human beings are merely
one aspect of nature and thus go through the same phases of birth,
growth, decline and death. The Chinese know this and don't fight tooth
and nail against getting older the way Americans are prone to doing. It
would be unthinkable for a Chinese woman in her 60s to contemplate
plastic surgery to erase facial lines. The face throughout Chinese
culture has been thought of as the canvas for character and personality.
To artificially take away these character lines, which elderly people
in China often view as their badge of experience, would be absurd. They
are far more likely to be concerned with maintaining a healthy head of
hair which, in keeping with Chinese medical theory, shows their good
blood and kidney essence. This is why both older men and women often
take he shou wu (literally "black-haired Mr. He") to nourish
their hair, and why it's not uncommon for people to color their hair
with black shoe polish! Vanity, as with beauty, would appear to also
affect all generations.
Hopefully more and more Americans can
learn to appreciate these Chinese ideas about graceful aging. The
Chinese seem to understand that by taking care of their health in their
younger years - staying socially involved with friends and family,
taking time on a daily basis to rest and relax, and finding stimulating
ways to use their minds and bodies - it is indeed possible to achieve a
kind of longevity. It may not be the immortality sought by the Taoist
sages, but it seems a much better quality of life than what's often
practiced in the West. I'd like to think that I'll be taking my
grandkids back and forth to school by bike like the Chinese when I'm in
my 70s. If not, maybe I'll move to China so I can play Mahjong, do tai
chi with my friends and get a little respect!
Afterword
The ancient world, in many ways infinitely more wise than our
own, acknowledged that the entirety of creation was in a process of ebb
and flow, from un-manifest potentiality to manifest existence. Our
planet exhibits this dynamic to us in the perennial cycle of the seasons
(the five phases) in periods of birth, growth, maturity, decline and
quiescence. We, too, according to the precepts of Chinese medicine,
participate in this same rhythm of being and non-being in our individual
lives. The Western world seemingly has harnessed its wagon to the
stars, ever looking upward and outward from terra firma.
Nevertheless, we are rooted here, and it is to that native soil - that
nourishing feminine matrix - that each of us must, in due course,
return.
Can we here in the West learn to acknowledge, like the
Chinese, that each step of the journey is of equal significance? Can we
learn from them how to mature gracefully, with dignity, embracing a way
of life that supports the elderly, respects wisdom and celebrates aging?
Most importantly, can we surrender our fear of impermanence and our
desperate grasping after an eternity of youth?